Expanding the Trades

Manitoba's school system overemphasizes university entrance, and the result is huge drop-out rates in universities and a shortage of skilled tradesmen. The German system of apprenticeship works better.
Published on September 25, 2006

 

Executive Summary

  • Manitoba suffers from a significant shortage of tradesmen.
  • Less than one-fourth of post-secondary students are currently enrolled in a vocational program.
  • Despite a promise in 1999 to “double college enrolment,” modest enrolment increases at community colleges have put Manitoba nowhere close to meeting that goal.
  • All three major universities have a much larger number of students. Unfortunately, most of these drop out before completing their programs.
  • Manitoba’s “mainstreaming” public schools are partially responsible. Students are forced to take a general academic program even if it is not suitable for them.
  • Germany provides a model for excellent streaming, in which students enter one of three different levels in lower secondary school.
  • As a result, about 65% of the workforce in Germany has received vocational training.
  • Many of the most popular vocational programs in Germany are the areas in which Manitoba is experiencing a labour shortage.
  • Manitoba’s government can redeem its promise if it makes changes to its mainstreaming policy at the K-12 level.

Full Backgrounder in PDF

 

Featured News

MORE NEWS

How DEI Is Hijacking The Future Of Legal Education

How DEI Is Hijacking The Future Of Legal Education

Senior Fellow Collin May spotlights Ilya Shapiro’s claim that DEI is warping legal education into activism training. Ideological conformity is replacing rigour, threatening free speech, legal neutrality, and the rule of law itself.

Teacher’s Striking

Teacher’s Striking

  In a recent Frontier commentary, Michael Zwaagstra argues that teacher strikes, such as those seen in Saskatchewan, unfairly disrupt student learning and should be replaced by binding arbitration—a system already in place in Manitoba. He contends that strikes...

Sick Of Teacher Strikes? There’s A Better Way

Sick Of Teacher Strikes? There’s A Better Way

Senior Fellow Michael Zwaagstra says it’s time to ban teacher strikes in Saskatchewan. Students shouldn’t be collateral damage. Binding arbitration works in Manitoba—so what’s the excuse here?