Stealth Equalization: How Federal Government Employment Acts as a Regional Economic Subsidy in Canada

Federal government employment is distributed unevenly across Canada. These jobs are found in high concentration in four out of the five major recipients of equalization – Manitoba, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and Prince Edward Island. Such uneven distribution amounts to a hidden form of wealth transfer worth more than $2 billion.
Published on November 15, 2010

 

Executive Summary

In a 2010 study, Frontier Centre analysts, including the author of this paper, outlined some of the negative unintended consequences of Canada’s equalization program. In particular, the study showed that equalization transfers have become so large that they result in the subsidization of relatively high levels of provincial spending on government programs in the have-not provinces. This has contributed to the development of disproportionately large public sectors in recipient provinces, and created disincentives for rational public policy that could increase ownsource revenues.
The official equalization program is, however, merely the tip of a much larger iceberg. There are a number of other ways that public policy in Canada extracts disproportionate amounts of tax revenues from residents of the most productive provinces and transfers that money to the large, inefficient public sectors that exist in the recipient provinces. The effect of these additional transfers is to exacerbate the problems caused by equalization- subsidizing disproportionately large and inefficient government in recipient provinces while burdening taxpayers in paying provinces with higher taxes.
Other components of public policy that create significant transfers of money from taxpayers in more productive provinces to governments in less productive provinces constitute a form of “stealth equalization,” which exists alongside Canada’s official equalization program.
This paper examines a major component of this system of stealth equalization: regionally unbalanced federal government employment. Using Statistics Canada data, this paper shows that the federal government employs dramatically more public servants, as a proportion of the population, in the major equalization recipient provinces of Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, New Brunswick and Manitoba, than in other parts of the country.

View entire study as PDF (24 Pages)

 

 

 

Featured News

MORE NEWS

Black on Canada’s Proud Black History

Black on Canada’s Proud Black History

Did you learn any Black history in Black History Month? February came and went in Canada with few high-profile offerings, except a nod to a pioneering black athlete there and a slogan or commercial there. Black organizations sued the Canadian Human Rights Commission...

Why Are Canadian Home Prices So High?

Why Are Canadian Home Prices So High?

In the last 8 years, we have seen home costs double across Canada. There are many reasons for the rise in prices and it is difficult to connect the increases to just one particular reason. In your opinion how would you rank the reasons listed below as the main causes...

NDP Premier Thinks Big on Economic Transformation

NDP Premier Thinks Big on Economic Transformation

Despite many who would never dare believe it, Premier Wab Kinew has come out said he would like to become a transformational economic leader in our province. The evidence? Well, not too long ago at an event held at the Manitoba Chamber of Commerce Kinew addressed an...