Cultural Transformation: From The Classroom To The Public Square

A popular quote asserts, “The philosophy of the school room in one generation will be the philosophy of government in the next.” Schooling has never been a neutral enterprise. Disputes […]
Published on October 2, 2023

A popular quote asserts, “The philosophy of the school room in one generation will be the philosophy of government in the next.” Schooling has never been a neutral enterprise.

Disputes over the control of education and what children should learn have been with us for centuries.

One of the most troubling cultural battles in post-Confederation Canadian history was known as the “Manitoba Schools Crisis.”

Manitoba’s entry into the Canadian Confederation in 1870 was dependent on an agreement to set up separate school systems that would protect French-speaking Catholic Métis against cultural domination by growing numbers of English-speaking secularists. The original Manitoba Act granted constitutional protection for religious schools that had existed by law or practice at the time of the union.

Over the next several years, many French Catholic Métis chose to move further west. A cultural battle in Manitoba was triggered by a series of controversial laws supported by the growing Anglo-Protestant majority.

An 1890 Manitoba “Public Schools Act” ended funding for Catholic and Protestant education and established a system of tax-supported “non-denominational” schools. The era of the Manitoba crisis coincided with the beginning of the end for faith-informed liberal education and the dawn of progressive schooling.

False Promises of ‘Progress’

The 20th century ushered in promises of continuous human progress and permanent transformation.

In politics, reform liberals and progressives pledged to produce universal human flourishing through the managerial skills of government experts.

Marxists sought to overthrow bourgeois rule and replace it with a “dictatorship of the proletariat.” When the working class declined to join the revolution, neo-Marxists turned to identity politics and the long march through the institutions. Schools were at the top of their target list.

In colonial North America, faith and continuity played an important role in the lives of settlers and the indigenous peoples who converted to Christianity. Up to the latter decades of the 19th century, most schools were organized by religious orders.

Over the past few generations, leftist intellectuals have eviscerated classical liberal education. From early progressives such as John Dewey to the “Critical Pedagogy” of Paulo Freire and “grievance studies” in modern faculties of education, teachers have been directed to “teach the child and not the subject.”

Today, students are being deliberately estranged from their parents and groomed to participate in every radical “woke” political movement under the sun. “Political literacy” is the goal. Actual literacy has been declining for decades.

This summer, the Louis Riel School Division (LRSD) in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, triggered a 21st-century version of their province’s 19th-century schools crisis. Winnipeg school trustees joined a global list of militant activists committed to the deconstruction of traditional values and the transformation of Western civilization.

In June, the LRSD unanimously voted to suspend a fellow trustee for three months without pay when someone reported that she had privately expressed views critical of transgender ideology on her Facebook page.

CBC News reported that trustee Francine Champagne was publicly accused of targeting the “2SLGBTQIA+ community” and causing harm to the entire division. According to the CBC, LRSD Chair Sandy Nemeth categorically declared Ms. Champagne’s conservative views to be disrespectful, hateful, transphobic, and homophobic.

Many citizens viewed the behavior of the school division as a “witch-hunt” and protested the trustee’s suspension at a final June board meeting. Later in the summer, the LRSD superintendent sent those who had objected to the suspension a “no-trespass” letter forbidding them access to any of the school division’s properties.

To head off more objections from the public and clashes with transgender militants, the first September LRSD meeting was conducted in a restricted virtual session at a venue to which citizens were forbidden entry. The entire affair has been a sterling example of Herbert Marcuse’s “repressive tolerance” in action.

School teachers used to be guided by tested traditions and scholarly academics. The ethos that guides them today is filled with Marxist illusions, divisive identity politics, and out-of-control neo-paganism. Governing authorities are literally sacrificing impressionable young people to the caprices of woke ideology.

In a summer edition of First Things magazine, editor R.R. Reno wrote, “One need not have a degree in child psychology to recognize how distressed children become when there is no stability or structure in their lives, no settled expectations, no concept of the normal.”

What’s to Be Done?

As I write this from my home in Nova Scotia, a local nonpartisan group of parents and citizens is organizing a public demonstration outside of Halifax City Hall.

The organizers want to protest the “sexualization of children, grooming and the undermining of parental rights.” They seek to assert that it’s “the duty and responsibility of parents to provide for the well-being of their children and to protect them from all undue and harmful influences from all outside forces.” Similar school governance conflicts and popular demonstrations have been occurring throughout North America.

Over the coming election cycles in Canada and the United States, it’ll be interesting to see whether or not establishment politicians are listening and what, if anything, they’re prepared to do about the corrosive educational practices of the “Woke” Reich.



William Brooks is a Senior Fellow at Frontier Centre for Public Policy.  Originally appeared here.

Featured News


Rodney Hide: My Journey

Rodney Hide: My Journey

It’s been awhile since I have written. I have tried. But I have not had anything useful to say. My concern has always been public policy. What should the government do for the best result? My writing on the government was technical. Here’s what the government is...

Talk Truth – Francine Champagne

Talk Truth – Francine Champagne

In this episode of Talk Truth, Allen and Corri Hunsperger sit down with Francine Champagne, a former Manitoba school trustee whose steadfast principles led her through intense political and social adversity. Francine discusses her motivations for running for school...

Sadly, AFN Remains Bad Venue for Future-Oriented Prosperity Message

Sadly, AFN Remains Bad Venue for Future-Oriented Prosperity Message

Manitoba’s First Nations should reflect on the AFN’s direction as they consider negative reactions to Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre at a recent Assembly of First Nations (AFN) meeting in Montreal. Poilievre, who in the past has boldly said we need to end the...