Resource Royalties vs. Rent Control

New RLP columnist's very unfortunate choice of analogy...
Published on March 17, 2011

The Regina Leader Post has a new columnist named Greg Fingas with his first column published today. The blurb says he writes “about provincial and national issues from a progressive NDP perspective.” Fair enough.

The column, though, is an incredibly bad piece of work. I know because I’ve written similar ones from time to time, and they’re hard to be proud of. I can see Fingas thinking “damn, I haven’t done any research, but I really want to write this. Hmmm, maybe I could spin out a Goldie-Locks style analogy to 700 words?”

Which is what he’s done.

Imagine a Regina home builder just like any other, with one important exception.

Back in 2002, the builder thought long and hard about what prices to charge in a market that hadn’t seen substantial price changes for a long time. And so it developed a price list that it hasn’t changed since…

And so it goes on, painfully making the point that the markets have changed but the Potash royalty formula has remained the same.

A much better report is here. It is almost entirely based on quotes from Potash Corp’s CFO, but I know that Bruce Johnstone would have checked the facts.

What I really want to know, though, is: Based on his long analogy about the problem with depressing building costs, does Finga oppose rent control?

Featured News

MORE NEWS

Like It Or Loathe It, The Coalition Is Cracking on

Like It Or Loathe It, The Coalition Is Cracking on

Say what you like about the coalition Government - and there are plenty of opinions - but it is clearly a Government determined to change New Zealand in the direction that it campaigned on, and quickly. The announcement made by Housing and Infrastructure Minister...

What Does Canada Day Mean Today?

What Does Canada Day Mean Today?

It’s Canada Day. A day that used to be a celebration of cherished values like kindness and compassion, acceptance and tolerance, quiet strength and dignity, and a work hard/play hard ethic. Today, I am celebrating the very fine Canadian men and women I have met since...

Toronto, Vancouver Named ‘Impossibly Unaffordable’

Toronto, Vancouver Named ‘Impossibly Unaffordable’

While Vancouver can be beautiful, it has also been deemed the most unaffordable city in Canada by a Demographia International Housing Affordability report and the third-least affordable city of the 94 markets analyzed in the report.